"Prometheus",
or as it could be subtitled, "Why are they doing that, it seems really
dangerous and stupid?"
I saw this
the weekend it came out, which is very uncharacteristic of me, as I am
incredibly cheap, but it looked like a really genre defining movie. To be honest I have never been a fan of the
"Alien" franchise, it is only okay in my opinion, as the first movie
is rather boring, and I actually have had no drive to see the others.
There is
nothing in this movie I did not understand.
It did not go over my head, I've read about this soon to be tired
concept many times. The only thing that
escapes me is what was going on in the minds of the shitty characters. People react to things so inconsistently with
how a normal person would react (with notable exceptions) that it detaches you
from the movie, and grows frustrating.
"Looks poisonous, let me have a lick." "Is that barbed? Let me check by shoving it up my own
ass."
"Jesus, I know we transported down to dangerous locations all the time, but we never had a budget for cool space suits, its not like we had them and didn't use them correctly." |
Let me go
over the things I liked. I liked the
main character in spite of her "faith", which is a major point of
stupidity in the movie, she openly states that she believes and acts on assumptions
she makes without evidence (I can't remember the character's name). I liked the Captain in spite of him leaving
more than one crew member to die in an alien fortress so he could dip his dick
in Charlize Theron, honestly she is so pretty and the characters he left to die
were so annoying I can't really hold it against him (can't remember his name
either). I liked Michael Fassbender's performance so much that I think he
should get a best supporting actor nod (though the character does numerous
things that make no sense, even in context, even after you have seen the whole
movie). And I really like Charlize
Theron, she was a really cool character who was frequently the most level
headed and sensible (so of course the movie tries to make her look like the bad
guy through a good chunk) (SPOILER: she dies in a really stupid way).
I very much
enjoyed the look of the movie, the Alien colony/base is really creepy and alien
in its appearance, because Giger knows how to make alien things look actually
alien. There are several good
scenes. And the ending I feel works, for
the most part (though there is a certain cheapness to it).
I typed "Cheap Sci-fi Ending" into google, and this image from "Prometheus" was in the top 15 results. |
What I
dislike is so numerous I think I will have a hard time listing it all to
completion. Chief is this: Characters
don't act intelligently or with any sense of self preservation aside from those
few I liked (and I primarily only liked them because of that trait). The dialogue does not make sense with what is
on the screen many times, with people wondering if the massive obvious
structures, runways, and faces carved into mountains are artificial
constructs. The idea that these
scientists just confirmed extraterrestrial life and they are not all ecstatic
for such a discovery. And good god: the
tired stereotypes that appear that have no place in this type of film, those
tropes were made fun of in "Cabin in the Woods" earlier this year.
I dislike
the way people rudely treat the Android character, David (Michael Fassbender),
who is for all intents and purposes a human being with intelligence and a will
of his own. I can understand talking to
him like a subordinate, he is there to assist, but it comes off so
dickish. I sympathize with the character
and I just see him as a character in a movie. The characters in the movie actually interact
with him, shouldn't somebody talk to him as if he were a person using
"please" and "Thank you" and asking him his opinion? I mean, the idea of a sentient machine has
existed for so long in science fiction I would like to think that if a group of
forward thinking, planet hoping, diverse and adventurous super scientists met a
thinking Machine they would be less obnoxious and more curious and open. These scientists probably grew up in a world
were movie making technology was hyper immersive (as evidenced by the hologram
technology they used) and since these are scientists they probably are not
unfamiliar with Science Fiction presented very convincingly. These scientists would not be this thick
headed... they're fucking scientists.
There is also a lot of goo in this movie. So much so that at one point all I could think of was that scene from "Ghostbusters 2" when Ray yells, "SLIME! ITS A RIVER OF SLIME!" |
There are
also little things that just don't make sense from a practical standpoint. They don't take weapons with them on their
initial exploration of the alien structure, and take off protective gear in
situations that no sane person would do so (I said, "put your fucking
helmet on" out loud in the theater, and had to stifle myself half way
through the sentence). Characters act
maddeningly inconsistent (at one point the map maker, who has his own scouting
robots, gets lost in the facility).
There are twists so lame, that when they were "revealed" to
the audience people saw it telegraphed from a mile away (one reveal actually
had a guy in the back of the theater say the word, "GASP" in the flattest
tone I have heard this side of Ben Stein).
And I would
say that is my biggest complaint: this movie is dumb. It has a consistent tone, cool realistic
appearance (to a point, the last monster and space gods looked very CGI). It is just that people make way too many
objectively bad decisions for people who are trusted with representing mankind
on a 100 billion dollar space exploration mission to find intelligent life. And being a person who doesn't usually get
mad at movies, this one pissed me off.
Which is a shame, the questions they meant to leave unanswered were
thought provoking. It's like a really
beautiful a delicious looking cake, that someone walked in and shit on. You shit on my Ace of Cakes. It was something great marred by stupid and
that makes it all the worse.
I am
actually thinking of more stuff to complain about, as I am sitting down to
publish it, I could go on for pages. And
others have. SHIT ON MY CAKE!
Ace of Cakes. Like that, but with Shit on it. |