I have not been posting nearly enough this year and I want to steer back
from that. To that end I have found a 30-day blog challenge and
fluffed it out to 31 entries (since December has 31 days). I have
done a 30-day
challenge before for movies, though that one was poorly executed (I started
it in the middle of a month, at one point I posted 2 entries on one day, it is
a mess). I did another one just this year in August on Video
Games, that one was better, go read it after this
one, all of it. Or don’t, no pressure.
Today is
day 29 and the topic is “Favorite Happy Ending”.
I thought
about making this the last entry for the month, but decided to instead go with
the really long Top List spread over two days and mostly referencing earlier
entries in the month. I think it will
all work out.
Spoilers for this entry. Obviously.
It is about endings. I mean, I
guess a bunch of Disney stuff is drawn from Fairy Tales and you can generally
accept that happily ever after will follow a triumphant defeat of the bad guys
by the good guys, spoiling that is not gonna ruin anything. Disney is not hiring Lars Van Trier to make
his version of… anything. So, let’s make
this a top 6, because I don’t want to just point at one movie and then talk
about its epilogue. That is a little too
easy.
Generally speaking, there are only
two types of endings in Disney films.
The first type is the one everybody knows and expects, “And they lived Happily Ever After.” Knowing that the
rewards earned in this adventure defined the character’s lives till the end is
a satisfying way to give the audience closure.
The second ending, which I feel is
more common these days—for reasons I pointed out in the “Best Sequel” entry—is,
“And The Adventure Continues…” which in
contrast to “Happily”, this ending indicates that this is only the first of
many tales yet untold. This sort of denouement
fires the audience’s imagination, not just to hope for future movies, but to
imagine their own adventures for the characters and world. I generally prefer this type, as I think
people need to be encouraged to think about doing more and going on their own
adventures, instead of just waiting for their “ending” to come to them.
These are the two most common and
the best ways to end a movie. So before
we talk about those, let’s talk about a shitty ending.
There is a third type that I think
most people would agree with me is the worst.
The ending that just stops. There
are elements of the story left unanswered but no promise of future adventures
to resolve them, Disney doesn’t run into this issue too often and off the top
of my head I can only point to one strong example, “The Sword in the Stone”.
Generally speaking, if your movie's ending is someone having a fantastic destiny thrust upon them thru no will of their own, Then you are writing the story backwards. Think of how many stories start with some goober being told they are "The Special"? Here is an example, "You're a wizard, Harry." |
You cannot tell me that the most
interesting time in King Arthur’s life was BEFORE he became king. Why are we not looking at the more
interesting part of his life? It is not
like the movie is too long, it is 79 minutes, you could easily integrate more
of the legend in there.
Show some more adventures. Make him a little older, have him face off
against the Black Knight, throw in Guinevere as a love interest, hint at how
important the holy Grail will one day be to Camelot. The existing final resolution of the movie
isn’t even good as an ending. It is
resolved entirely by accident. If not
for the knight he is squiring for needing a sword Arthur would have never even
seen the sword. He has no concept of the
importance of the action and no real agency in assuming his destiny. “BLEH!”
I say. “BLEH!”
Note: There is a bunch of Pixar on
this list. There is a reason that
company has had such an impact on family entertainment these last 20 years.
Top 3 for “Happily Ever After”
“Up”
Coming to the realization that your
life was worth living and that the memories made are something to be treasured
even if it was not the life you dreamed of is a good lesson. There is also the lesson that you can make a
go of adventuring at any point in your life and it still be a harrowing and
worthwhile experience that will be enriching.
And there is also a lesson about how it is never too late to try and
pass on what you have learned about life to the next generation and use what
you know to serve as a mentor and fatherly figure to the young and that such
things are valuable to both the young person and the mentor.
This movie is deep.
“Wall-E”
I love me some robots, but I am
only lukewarm on this movie overall. It
is cute but it sure as hell is not subtle, I actually think that “Wall-E” has contributed
to a modern Luddite type thinking, as stupid people resisting the advent of
more automated systems in day to day life, “We can’t have self-driving cars, it
will put too many drivers out of work.”
Completely ignoring that the ultimate end of the movie was not an
abandonment of technology and automated systems, but using those systems as a
means to free up time to better spend it appreciating life and the natural
world.
The end of the movie is a call to
action on the environment and to cast off the most comically over the top
lampooning of consumerism ever put to film.
These are not bad morals.
I would also like to point out a
good bit of narrative structure. The
conflict of the movie, that we not only care about getting back to Earth, but
we also care about saving Wall-E from his mortal injuries, keeps the film
exciting. Contrast this with the “Lorax”
CGI movie in which they are racing to plant a tree at the end of the movie, but
no one’s life is at stake. Weak ending.
Writing tip, to complicate and
deepen the narrative in the third act, don’t just re-emphasize the initial goal,
instead throw in an additional twist which will heighten the tension on an
emotional level. “Wall-E” is a good
example of this in action, another good example? “The Empire Strikes Back”, not enough to just
defeat Vader, but since Vader is your dad, you now have to defeat your own
potential to fall to the dark side. That
is meaningful.
I keep banging on about this movie,
and its ending is why I keep doing so.
Almost the entire rest of the movie could be cut out except for the
scene of Andy giving his toys away and it would still be the best happily
(sadly) ever after out there.
Top 3 for “And the Adventures Continue!”
“Aladdin”
I really liked the sequel cartoon
growing up. Aladdin and crew were a medieval
fantasy land Avengers in the 90’s that I watched each day after school, they
had a colorful cast of villains and supporting characters with a range of
motivations and methodology. That being
said, does the MOVIE set up the SERIES well by leaving the audience with the
feeling that things will go on? I think
so.
Genie is set free and wants to see
the world but remains a grateful friend of Aladdin, which promises a return. The Sultan clearly has plans for Aladdin, and
Al being aware of the poverty in the city will bring a fresh perspective to the
palace about the state of the city and the value of its people. Lastly, the world is still riff with potential
for adventure, the original “Aladdin” story comes from a set of “1,001 Arabian
Nights” which is name checked multiple times in the movie, that is a hint at a world that is rich with stories to tell. (You might say, "A Whole New World"). This ending feels like the start of something more, and more came down
the pipe.
The fact that this thing was not
turned into a massive franchise is baffling to me. IT ENDS WITH THE START OF ANOTHER
ADVENTURE! It’s a superhero story which
talks about there being lots of bad guys and lots of history. This should be more movies!
The movie
ends with a montage showing the complex and strange emotions of dozens of
people. “Inside Out” was one big event
in the life of someone who has a whole life full of big events waiting for her
to go thru them. Not to mention all the
people of the world going thru life changing events and the swirl of
conflicting emotions that come with each.
We are all tiny little universes and each has stories to tell.
The Beg for Attention
Share your
own thoughts on this in the comments. I
know I am not the only person out there who is nostalgic for Disney products,
and I am sure many people disagree with my selection for today’s entry.
I picked Disney stuff just because
I knew there was so much of it to talk about and it lends itself to discussion
in the comments.
What is your favorite
ending for a Disney movie?
Or family
movie in general?
What is your
favorite 3rd act twist?
Do you think I am giving “Up too much credit?
Share your thoughts below.
______________________________
I don't have answers for the other questions, but I agree with you on Up. Really solid movie.
ReplyDeleteThank you, I just went thru and read every comment that you wrote. I do not usually get so much feedback and looking at your blogs I can tell we cover very different material, so that is all the more surprising.
DeleteYeah, just slightly different! :) I found your blog through the Cracked article on Disney stuff yesterday.
Delete